top of page
Writer's pictureLawpointuganda

Court Rules That Lawyer Comments About Judges Is Not Protected Speech.


A US Court in the state of Ohio, has ruled in the case of Cleveland Metro. Bar Ass’n v. Morton, Ohio, No. 2021-Ohio-4095 that, "That Unfounded attacks on a Judicial Officer warrants discipline." An Ohio lawyer was suspended for one year with six months stayed for unjustly attacking the integrity of judges who ruled against him in a real estate case, the state’s high court said.


John Alex Morton’s “unfounded attack against the judiciary warrants an actual suspension from the practice of law,” the Ohio Supreme Court said Tuesday.

When Morton appealed the valuation of his client’s property, he argued that the appeals court’s ‘political agenda’ motivated its ruling against his client, the disciplinary decision said. He also alleged the state high court deliberately delayed a decision on whether to hear his appeal.

At his disciplinary hearing, Morton alleged that his allegations were protected by the First Amendment.

Morton acted with “reckless disregard for the truth of his accusations” because he didn’t make any investigation before his “undignified and discourteous statements” about the judges, and thus isn’t protected by the First Amendment, the high court said.

The court agreed with its disciplinary board that Morton’s conduct violated ethics rules on engaging in conduct intended to disrupt a tribunal and prejudicial to the administration of justice.

Morton has no prior discipline, it said. He didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.

16 views0 comments

Comments


WhatsApp Image 2024-12-03 at 18.32.53_b97c34af.jpg

LEAVE A REPLY

Thanks for submitting!

Writing in Notepad

Write for Us

Appointing New Writers

We're actively seeking passionate researchers and writers to join our team. If you're enthusiastic about sharing knowledge and contributing to our platform, we'd love to hear from you. Don't hesitate to apply – your expertise could make a significant impact on our community's learning experience.

Green Modern Real Estate Agent Linkedin Banner (1).jpg

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Be the first to know about our events, conferences, workshops, live training and consultations.

SUCCESSFULLY SUBSCRIBED!

Green Modern Real Estate Agent Linkedin Banner.jpg
bottom of page